Back to News
News

Solskjaer open to United return but backs under-fire Carrick

OwnOdds AI analysis4 min read3 sources
How this story was produced

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is receptive to another Manchester United spell but supports Michael Carrick. His comments leave bigger questions about United’s next decision unanswered.

Solskjaer open to United return but backs under-fire Carrick
In this article

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has indicated he would consider managing Manchester United again, while backing Michael Carrick to remain in charge after Saturday’s 2-0 defeat at Chelsea deepened scrutiny of his position.

In comments to Norwegian broadcaster TV2, the former United manager described a continuing attachment to the club and an interest in another opportunity. But he also made clear that he was not seeking to replace Carrick, presenting a possible return as something that could happen well into the future rather than an immediate ambition.

That distinction matters. Solskjaer’s availability adds a familiar name to the discussion surrounding United’s next move, but the supplied reports establish neither a fresh approach from the club nor an active campaign by him for the job.

An expression of interest, not a new appointment process

The reports agree that United considered both men after Ruben Amorim’s departure earlier this year, before choosing Carrick. They also describe a similar career pattern: each initially took temporary charge before earning a permanent appointment.

There is, however, a difference in how the earlier recruitment process is presented. Some accounts describe Solskjaer as having been interviewed for the interim position. The fuller account of his TV2 comments characterises his contact with executives Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada as a short discussion, without negotiations or agreement over contract duration.

Those descriptions are not necessarily incompatible, but they leave the formality of his candidacy unclear. Being willing to help, discussing a role and negotiating an appointment are different stages. The available reporting does not establish that Solskjaer reached the last of them.

His stated expectation that any assignment would end by the summer also gives that earlier conversation a narrower scope than a permanent comeback. There is no basis to assume that the same arrangement would now appeal to either party.

Support that complicates the succession debate

Solskjaer’s endorsement of Carrick is more substantial than a passing expression of goodwill. Across the accounts, he points to Carrick’s understanding of United, his connection with supporters and a competitive edge that may not be obvious from his public manner.

One report also carries his account of recommending Carrick during his own discussions with the club. Taken together, those details weaken the suggestion that his remarks amount to an attempt to dislodge a former colleague.

Nevertheless, intention and effect can diverge. When an incumbent is struggling, a previous manager’s willingness to return inevitably becomes part of the succession debate. Solskjaer can sincerely support Carrick while his comments still increase public attention on alternatives.

The more important question for United is what another appointment would be designed to change. Both men bring extensive knowledge of the institution. If that familiarity is central to the argument for retaining Carrick, it cannot by itself explain why replacing him with Solskjaer would produce a different outcome.

That would require a clearer assessment of coaching, squad suitability and the responsibilities surrounding the head coach. None of the reports supplies a detailed case from United’s decision-makers on those issues.

Roma brings a different kind of pressure

According to the reporting, United’s hierarchy discussed Carrick’s position before the Chelsea match but allowed him to continue. One account says he is not expected to be dismissed before Tuesday’s Champions League meeting with Roma. That is an indication of the immediate timetable, not confirmation of longer-term security.

The domestic results explain why the discussion has persisted. As of 31 October, United had won once, drawn four times and lost three times in eight Premier League matches. The issue is therefore broader than the defeat at Stamford Bridge: too many league games have ended without a victory.

Europe presents a separate test. The Manchester United versus Roma prediction gives United a 63% chance of winning, with a draw at 19% and a Roma victory at 18%. Those probabilities make the hosts favourites for this fixture; they do not establish that United’s underlying problems have been resolved.

A win could ease the immediate pressure without answering the domestic concerns. Equally, a disappointing result would add scrutiny but would not, on its own, explain which structural or managerial changes United need.

With Aston Villa due at Old Trafford on Sunday before the international break, Carrick faces two important home matches. Solskjaer’s comments offer a potential option, not a settled solution. The unresolved issue is less whether a familiar former manager would answer a call than whether United have identified precisely what their current team is missing.

How this story was produced

This article was written by an AI model working from the reports linked above together with our own form and prediction data, and published automatically — it is not reviewed by a person before it goes live. It is original prose rather than a reproduction of the source reporting; facts and quotes belong to the outlets credited, and the links go to their original work.

Automated writing gets things wrong. If you spot an error, please tell us — we correct factual mistakes and say on the page when we have.

Share this story
TagsOle Gunnar SolskjaerMichael CarrickManchester UnitedManchester United managerManchester United vs Roma

Prediction for one of these teams

Matches involving the clubs in this story, with our model's call and the reasoning behind it.