Sandro Tonali was left out of Tottenham’s squad to face Ipswich Town on Saturday after Roberto De Zerbi revealed that the midfielder had been unwell for several days. His absence formed part of a broader reshuffle, with six changes to the team beaten at Leeds before the international break.
The immediate distinction is important: De Zerbi attributed Tonali’s omission to illness, not an injury. The pre-match reports supplied no diagnosis beyond that explanation and offered no recovery timetable. Tottenham therefore have an availability concern, but there is not yet evidence of a longer-term physical setback.
The Italian’s absence also came amid several different selection pressures. Rodrigo Bentancur was among the substitutes after returning late from international duty, while Mathys Tel and Mykhailo Mudryk were reported injured. Those circumstances make the scale of De Zerbi’s changes easier to understand, without establishing that every alteration was enforced.
A reshuffle with more than one explanation
According to Saturday’s reports, De Zerbi linked his selection both to players’ physical readiness and to the defeat at Leeds. That matters when assessing what the revised team says about his preferences. This was neither a straightforward response to a poor result nor simply an exercise in replacing unavailable players.
James Maddison, Destiny Udogie, Marcos Senesi, Conor Gallagher, Dominic Solanke and teenager Luca Williams-Barnett entered the starting side. Williams-Barnett’s inclusion was particularly notable because it represented his first senior start for Tottenham, following substitute appearances against Crystal Palace and Leeds.
Yet the number of changes alone cannot establish a lasting change in the pecking order. Tonali could not be selected, Bentancur had barely rejoined the group, and Tel was injured. Any assessment of De Zerbi’s preferred side needs to separate those constraints from decisions made on performance grounds.
Bentancur’s presence on the bench also illustrates why being available and being ready to start are not necessarily the same thing. De Zerbi said the midfielder had only returned to work with Tottenham on Friday. That provides context for his selection, although it does not establish any medical restriction on his involvement.
Tonali’s importance is clear, his return date is not
The reports describe Tonali’s recent involvement differently. One highlights starts in Tottenham’s previous four league matches; another says he had started all 10 Premier League games before Saturday. Those accounts are not inherently incompatible, but only the latter makes the broader claim that he had been ever-present in the starting team.
The shared conclusion is narrower and secure: Tonali had been a regular selection immediately before his omission. Losing that continuity complicates a midfield adjustment already affected by Bentancur’s late return.
One report also notes that Tonali started both of Italy’s Nations League matches during the international break, playing 62 minutes against Belgium last Sunday. That establishes his recent involvement, not the cause of his illness. There is no basis in the available reporting to attribute his condition to international workload or to suggest that an earlier substitution signalled the same problem.
Nor does De Zerbi’s failure to flag the issue at Friday’s press conference prove that Tottenham expected Tonali to recover in time. That is one possible explanation, but the reports do not establish when the final decision was made. The reliable update remains the explanation given after the team was announced.
The attacking changes deserve separate scrutiny
Tonali’s absence is only one part of the selection story. Tottenham had failed to score in five of their opening 10 league matches, according to the pre-match reporting. That gives the attacking changes a significance beyond the need to cover an unavailable midfielder.
Maddison’s inclusion in the central attacking role, Solanke’s return to the starting side and Williams-Barnett’s opportunity on the left altered several elements of the attack at once. In analytical terms, that creates a challenge as well as an opportunity: changing multiple positions makes it harder to isolate which adjustment improves the team’s play.
De Zerbi expressed confidence in the depth of his squad, but Saturday’s selection was not a clean test of strength in reserve. It combined illness, injuries, differing preparation time and a response to defeat. Until Tottenham provide another update, Tonali’s situation is best understood as a confirmed illness-related absence with an uncertain duration, rather than evidence of a more serious problem.