Borussia Dortmund vs FC St. Pauli Preview (Bundesliga 2025)
Borussia Dortmund welcome FC St. Pauli to Signal Iduna Park in a classic top‑versus-bottom clash, with Niko Kovač’s side firmly in the title race and Alexander Blessin battling to drag St. Pauli out of the relegation zone. On form, quality and momentum, everything points toward a strong home win.
Our model leans towards a 3-0 Dortmund victory, driven by their potent attack and a growing defensive stability despite a key absence at the back.
---
Current Form and Momentum
Dortmund’s recent form line of 5 wins, 4 draws and 1 defeat in their last 10 matches (22 scored, 11 conceded) is exactly what you expect from a side sitting second in the table. They’ve been scoring at 2.2 goals per game while allowing just 1.1, which is top-tier championship-contending output.
The performances back that up. The wild 3-3 draw with Eintracht Frankfurt showed their resilience, with Carney Chukwuemeka popping up in stoppage time to nick a point and underline the squad’s depth in attacking midfield. That was followed by a far more controlled, mature display in the 3-0 win over Werder Bremen, where Serhou Guirassy finally got his first league goal in eight games, a big psychological boost for their focal point up front.
St. Pauli’s last 10 tell a very different story: 3 wins, 3 draws, 4 defeats, with 12 goals scored and 11 conceded. The defensive record is respectable, but the attacking output of 1.2 goals per game is exactly why they’re 17th. They’ve tightened up in recent weeks – goalless draws against Bremen and Mainz and a gutsy 2-1 win against Wolfsburg – but those results have come from deep, hard‑working performances rather than sustained attacking control.
Over a 90-minute contest against an in‑form Dortmund in full flow, that difference in ceiling matters a lot.
---
Tactical Match‑Up
Dortmund under Niko Kovač
Kovač has leaned heavily into a 3-4-2-1:
- Back three: Süle and Anton are the mainstays, offering physicality and strong aerial presence. With Schlotterbeck out, Emre Can is a logical pick on the left of the three, giving flexibility to step into midfield.
- Wing‑backs: Yan Couto on the right and Julian Ryerson on the left provide width and constant running. They pin back opposition wing‑backs and are key to Dortmund’s territorial dominance.
- Double pivot: Marcel Sabitzer and Felix Nmecha combine control and vertical passing. Sabitzer dictates tempo, while Nmecha can break lines with carries.
- Attacking line: Julian Brandt and Chukwuemeka between the lines feeding Guirassy gives Dortmund plenty of creativity and physical presence in the box.
At home, this shape allows Dortmund to camp in the opposition half, send numbers forward and still protect transitions reasonably well, especially with Can’s mobility at the back.
St. Pauli under Alexander Blessin
Blessin has largely stuck to a 3-4-1-2, as we’ve seen against Wolfsburg and Mainz:
- A back three of Dźwigała, Wahl and Mets that is strong in the air but can be turned by quick combination play.
- Wing‑backs Pyrka and Ritzka who work tirelessly but can get pinned deep by superior wide players.
- Midfield hinges on James Sands and Eric Smith for ball-winning and simple circulation.
- Jackson Irvine as the advanced midfielder brings late runs and leadership.
- Up front, combinations of Joel Fujita, Ricky-Jade Jones, Hountondji or Pereira Lage rely on work rate and direct running rather than elite finishing.
Against Dortmund’s 3-4-2-1, St. Pauli risk being pushed into a 5-3-2 low block. They will look to frustrate and counter, but once Dortmund take the lead, Blessin’s side lack the firepower and creativity to chase the game without opening themselves up.
---
Key Missing Players and Injury Impact
The standout absentee is Nico Schlotterbeck for Dortmund, sidelined with a jumper’s knee.
Schlotterbeck is crucial in several ways:
- Progression: He’s one of Dortmund’s best vertical passers from the back, often breaking lines with his left foot.
- Aggression: He defends on the front foot, stepping into midfield to cut out counters early.
- Set‑pieces: A regular aerial threat in the opposition box.
Without him, Kovač has a choice:
- Use Emre Can on the left of the back three, adding mobility and experience but sacrificing some height and pure defensive instincts in the last line.
- Or bring in R. Bensebaïni or a younger option like Anselmino if he wants a more natural left-sided defender.
Given recent lineups, Can is the most realistic Schlotterbeck replacement. The net effect:
- Slight downgrade in aerial security and left‑footed distribution.
- A bit more aggression stepping into midfield.
Against a side like St. Pauli that doesn’t rely on high-volume crossing or sustained possession, the impact is noticeable but not decisive. Dortmund might be a touch more vulnerable on a couple of counters, but they still have enough to keep control.
For St. Pauli, there are no major flagged absences from the listed squad, so Blessin can pick close to his strongest XI. The issue is less about who is missing and more about the overall quality level: even at full strength, this is a group built to fight relegation, not to go toe-to-toe with one of the league’s strongest squads.
In summary, the absence of Schlotterbeck hurts Dortmund’s upper ceiling slightly, but given the opponent and home advantage, it doesn’t fundamentally change the expectation of a comfortable win.
---
Head‑to‑Head and Historical Context
Recent meetings favour Dortmund clearly:
- Record (last 5): 3 wins Dortmund, 1 draw, 1 St. Pauli win
- Goals: 11 scored by Dortmund (2.2 per game), 6 conceded (1.2 per game)
The pattern is consistent: St. Pauli are usually competitive in spells, but Dortmund’s superior individual quality and attacking depth decide the tie over 90 minutes. With Dortmund now chasing Bayern at the top and St. Pauli stuck in 17th, that gap has arguably widened further.
---
Expected Goals (xG) Analysis
We can approximate xG trends from the available data and team profiles.
- Dortmund
- Goals scored last 10: 22 → estimated xG for ~1.9–2.1 per match.
- Goals conceded last 10: 11 → estimated xG against ~1.0–1.2 per match.
- They create a high volume of shots from good central areas and have strong set‑piece threats, which tends to sustain a high xG.
- St. Pauli
- Goals scored last 10: 12 → estimated xG for ~1.2–1.4 per match.
- Goals conceded last 10: 11 → estimated xG against ~1.2–1.4 per match.
- Their matches are generally low-event, but they concede territory and rely on compactness rather than chance suppression at elite levels.
The xG differential (xG for minus xG against) likely sits around +0.8–1.0 for Dortmund versus roughly neutral or slightly negative for St. Pauli. That kind of gap is massive over a single match, especially with Dortmund at home.
xG analysis supports:
- Dortmund to generate 2.0–2.5 xG in this game.
- St. Pauli to be limited to 0.6–0.9 xG given the step up in opponent quality.
That range aligns closely with a real‑world outcome around 2–3 goals for Dortmund and 0–1 for St. Pauli, which is why a 3-0 prediction fits the statistical picture.
---
Predicted Outcome and Scoreline
Bringing the form, tactics, injuries and xG picture together:
- Match winner probabilities: Dortmund ~72%, Draw ~18%, St. Pauli ~10%.
- Both Teams to Score leans slightly towards No (54%), largely because St. Pauli’s attacking threat is modest and Dortmund can control territory.
- Total goals: Over 2.5 has about a 62% edge, driven mainly by Dortmund’s firepower and likelihood of adding a late third if the game opens up.
Predicted scoreline: Borussia Dortmund 3–0 FC St. Pauli.
---
Value Bets vs 1xBet Odds
1xBet offers:
- 1X2: Dortmund 1.37 | Draw 5.33 | St. Pauli 10.00
- Over/Under 2.5: Over 1.76 | Under 2.23
- Both Teams to Score: Yes 2.03 | No 1.72
Comparing our probabilities to the market:
- Dortmund to win (1.37): Implied probability is roughly 73%. Our model has Dortmund at 72%, so this is very close to fair price, with only marginal value if any.
- Draw (5.33) / St. Pauli (10.00): We see the underdog outcomes as slightly more likely than the prices imply, but the edge isn’t big enough to justify a speculative punt given Dortmund’s dominance.
- Over 2.5 goals (1.76): Implied probability ~57%. Our estimate is ~62%, suggesting moderate value on the Over, driven by Dortmund’s capacity to score three on their own.
- BTTS – No (1.72): Implied probability ~58%. We have BTTS No at 54%. That’s a bit lower than the market, so not strong value.
Best value angles:
- Over 2.5 goals at 1.76 – modest but real edge, with Dortmund likely doing the heavy lifting.
- Dortmund win to nil (if priced attractively by the book) – our 3-0 line and BTTS probabilities imply a decent chance of a clean sheet.
---
Asian Handicap Predictions
The odds snippet lists only generic Asian prices, but the 1.37 home win price suggests a main line around Dortmund -1.5 or -1.25.
Given our predicted 3-0 score and a strong expectation of at least a two‑goal margin, here’s how the handicaps stack up conceptually:
- Dortmund -1.0: Very safe in our model – we expect them to win by at least one. Push protection if they only win by a single goal.
- Dortmund -1.25: Splits stake between -1.0 and -1.5. With our expectation centred on a 2–3 goal win, this looks like solid value if offered at a reasonable price.
- Dortmund -1.5: More aggressive but still well supported by our 3-0 prediction. Our margin distribution suggests a clear majority of Dortmund wins are by 2+ goals.
Given both sides’ form and the tactical edge, the best Asian Handicap play is Dortmund -1.5, or -1.25 if you want slightly more protection. St. Pauli will fight, but over 90 minutes, the quality gap should translate into a comfortable cushion on the scoreboard.
---
Key Players to Watch
- Serhou Guirassy (Dortmund) – Now back among the goals after breaking his mini‑drought against Bremen. His movement between centre‑backs and finishing in the box are central to Dortmund’s attacking ceiling.
- Julian Brandt (Dortmund) – The creative hub in the half-spaces. If he finds pockets between Sands and the back three, St. Pauli will struggle to contain the final pass.
- Carney Chukwuemeka (Dortmund) – Impactful in recent games, bringing late runs and composure in the final third. A real difference-maker against deep blocks.
- Jackson Irvine (St. Pauli) – The heartbeat of St. Pauli’s midfield. If he can drag his side upfield and win second balls, they might manufacture a few dangerous moments.
- James Sands & Eric Smith (St. Pauli) – Their ability to disrupt Dortmund’s rhythm in midfield is crucial if Blessin’s side are to keep this close.
Overall, though, the individual quality and depth in yellow and black should tell.
